23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing

What do we know about the most mysterious man in Rosewood?


1. Toby was blamed for his step-sister Jenna being blinded.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1001
But it was all just blackmail.

2. Chatting to him at school was social suicide.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1002

3. But Emily saw the real Toby.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1003
And they went to Homecoming together.

4. But was he really dangerous after all?

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1005
Could Toby have killed Alison?

5. Luckily Toby turned out to be a good guy and Spencer became his French tutor.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1006

6. It wasn't long before Spoby was born!

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1007

7. And we could all see what made Spencer swoon.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1009
From high school loser to sexy construction worker!

8. Spencer had to break Toby's heart to try and keep him safe.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1010
It was devastating.

9. It wasn't long before Toby was in Jenna's hands all over again.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1011

10. We all thought Toby hated Spencer and it killed us.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1012
But turns out he was just pretending!

11. We collectively fell in love with Spoby again until...Toby was unmasked as A?!

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1013
No!!!

12. A glimpse of Toby's infamous tattoo convinced Spencer that he was dead.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1014
And sent her down a terrible path.

13. But Toby was alive and had been faking his loyalty to the A Team all along.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1015

14. Spencer and Toby became awesome detectives.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1016
When they knew there was more to Toby's mom's death than Radley was letting on.

15. Shadow Play saw Toby absolutely rocking a fedora.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1017

16. Toby joined Rosewood's finest.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1018
He looked amazing in the uniform too.

17. And led the Rosewood police to A's lair.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1019

18. Before being suspended for accidentally getting high.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1020

19. Five years later and Toby is building a house for his girlfriend Yvonne.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1022
And Spoby are a thing of the past...or are they?

20. Back in the police force, Toby's involved in Charlotte DiLaurentis' murder investigation.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1023

21. We saw a new side to Toby when he punched Caleb for supposedly leaking sensitive information about Yvonne.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1024

22. And a flashback scene shows how a pregnancy scare drove Spoby apart when Spencer was in college.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1025

23. We left Spencer and Toby reminiscing, laughing and generally being kick ass together.

Pretty Little Liars - 23 Times Toby Cavanaugh Kept Us All Guessing - 1026
Could there be hope for Spoby after all? Only season 7 will tell.

What excitement do you think lies in Toby's future? Let us know below.


Up Next:

Pretty Little Liars - QUIZ: The ULTIMATE PLL Season 1 Trivia Quiz! - Up Next Thumb

QUIZ: The ULTIMATE PLL Season 1 Trivia Quiz!